I recently took it upon myself to write a letter to my local MP. Several people have suggested this over the past couple of years but I’ve finally actually managed it. Many thanks to the friends who have given this an extra once over for me.
Dear Lloyd Hatton,
I am writing to join the many 1000s of people who are terrified of the proposed changes to PIP and other health related benefits. My experience of applying for and renewing PIP for my wife has already been a horrible experience over the past few years. To highlight the severity of her mental health struggles: I have had to deal with many instances of self-harm and attempted suicide over the past decade. Additionally, she is currently sectioned under the mental health act and has been so for over 20 months. Before being sectioned, her PIP was removed several years ago, even though we had reported at her review that she was even worse than before. It was only reinstated due to intervention by the head of the perinatal mental health team for Dorset, who reiterated just how unwell she is.
It is an absolute horrific disgrace that an overly complex system that already treats vulnerable people with no compassion or empathy, is going to become even worse after proposed changes. I guarantee that this will lead to a great deal of people taking their own lives or simply dying due to isolation caused by their health conditions.
I am effectively a single parent bringing up two young boys, one of which is autistic, whilst also being an unpaid carer of a very sick spouse. I regularly receive tens of phone calls per day from my wife. These are typically because she is in a highly distressed state, convinced she is about to be killed by the characters of her psychotic delusions. During outings with her and the children, I have to keep an eye on her to ensure she is safe. It is exhausting. I am trying my best to ensure the children receive a healthy childhood and do not develop mental health issues due to the chaos that is going on around them. If my mental health were to drop any further, I very much fear for their own wellbeing.
I have been caring for my wife, Becky, for our entire 20-year relationship together. For a decade of this she has suffered with psychosis in addition to her long-standing anxiety and depression. We received nothing in terms of financial support for the first 15 years. I initially worked a 9-5 job. As she was unable to do so, we made do on just one salary and did not claim disability benefits for her, as this would have reinforced her self-view of being a “Burdon” and therefore not being worthy of living. However, when her anxiety worsened, I had to resign from my job, and we survived by using up our entire combined savings. I took a job for 6 hours per week, performing IT support in a school and attempted to earn more money by fixing people’s home computers.
I did return to full time work after around 18 months as we had run out of savings, however I had to find a company (pre-pandemic) who were happy for me to work from home several days per week. I reduced my hours in order to cope with Becky’s mental health around 12 years ago and continued to do so until finally having to admit defeat in January this year when I stopped working completely. In all the time that I was on reduced hours I received nothing in compensation, even though my reduced hours were a direct result of my own growing mental health issues, which are in turn a result of my wife’s mental health struggles.
When we were starting to struggle financially, I rang HMRC on my wife’s behalf to ascertain what disability benefits (Specifically at this time ESA) she was entitled to. I was shocked beyond belief that she was not eligible to claim anything. It would seem that, because it had been over 2 years since she had worked, she was not eligible and would never be eligible until such a time she COULD work for a year and then stop. Note: If she HAD been claiming for the previous 15 years she would still be entitled to do so. In essence, by saving HMRC £10,000s of pounds over the past 15 years we have, in fact, simply made our lives even harder.
Becky was under the care of the Community Mental Health Team (CMHT) 8 years ago after suffering her first severe episode of psychosis when we discovered Personal Independence Payments (PIP) even existed. Not a single person we’d had contact with previously had suggested it. This ranges from contact with GPs, to contact regarding Family Tax Credit etc. People who ARE eligible should be made aware at every opportunity! If we had knowledge previously it is highly likely she would have been eligible to claim sooner.
Currently, my wife’s PIP has been stopped because she is staying in a mental health unit. The black and white state of the rules have classed this as Becky being “In Hospital”. However, the unit to which she has been admitted aims to aid her recovery + rehabilitation which will allow her to become more independent. Becky, and all other patients, are actively encouraged to live as independently as possible whilst on the unit. Becky is not provided with food or meals; she has to buy her own groceries and cook/prepare these herself, suffering the same difficulties she faces while at home.
Personal hygiene products also have to be purchased and regular expenses such as eyecare, dentists, haircuts etc are also covered by Becky as if at home. When visiting home or going out she is required to organise transport. Given her anxiety, this usually requires me driving to and from the unit in our car, much as is the situation when she is home. This is more difficult for me currently as my own mental health and associated medication is making driving for prolonged periods extremely tiring. She is encouraged and is still trying very hard to be able to go independently on walks from the unit, but her condition makes this difficult in exactly the same way as at home.
Her ability to communicate with friends and family (which is limited by her condition) is reliant on her mobile phone, the cost of which again falls on her. If anything, since Becky was sectioned and admitted to hospital our family household costs have actually increased!
I am currently part way through a “Mandatory Reconsideration” regarding Becky’s PIP and I am having to spend what little mental capacity I have left making sure this is looked at. Services such as Citizens Advice and local Wellbeing Charities are helping me with this.
Additionally, because the entire situation over the past decade has completely destroyed my own mental health, I am unable to even contemplate returning to work. With the help of Citizens Advice and the same local charities I filled in a PIP application for myself which took a lot of energy. Upon receipt of my “Decision Letter” which stated I was not eligible I was flabbergasted to see that in the justification section, the entire section seemed to refer to someone else entirely mentioning operations I have not had and things I did not say.
After preparing myself and then ringing PIP it was confirmed that this entire section was not related to my claim but was for someone else!
This alone is a completely unacceptable situation which honestly, if it had happened to someone else could have led directly to their suicide.
I am now also going through a “Mandatory Reconsideration” for my own PIP. Everyone around me including counsellors, GPs, Social Workers and members of the team at Becky’s mental health unit, feel that I am only just holding on and need masses of support.
Meanwhile those that can offer support via PIP simply dismiss everything I have said and force me to have to fight every day. My mental health struggles are directly causing extra financial burden which is becoming more and more of an issue. For example, in order to keep the cleanliness of my home at an acceptable level and under the advice from the professionals mentioned above, I am having to incur the cost of employing a cleaner to come in once per week to clean my whole house. Additionally, to ensure continuity, I am paying for private counselling sessions to maintain the shreds of mental health that I have remaining.
Finally, I found out that although I have valid Sick Notes from my GP I am required to attend an interview to ascertain if I am fit for work in relation to my Universal Credit. Is my GP not qualified enough for this? Obviously, this assessment is via the external body who perform these assessments, who will have to pay a “Health Professional” to form the assessment which will likely be at great expense to the government. What if they disagree with my GP… do I have to ring my GP and inform them that they were wrong?
Having to deal with, and fight during all of this is quite literally killing me. My biggest achievement 20 years ago was getting a PhD; this month it was being able to focus enough to try and fry some onions and cook a meal!
It might sound glib, but the “Assisted Dying” legislation may take a back burner as it feels like the government are simply trying to push people to commit suicide via forcing them though the nightmare that is the benefit system.
I want to take this opportunity to highlight the amazing work being done by Citizens Advice in addition to local mental health charities to help people through. Local and national Government owe such organisations a huge debt. I am spending lots of my time at the Cosy Corner / Sanctuary on Portland, who are very much helping me avoid slipping into an unrecoverable mental health crisis.
As you can see above, I believe there is much work to do in order to ensure those who are vulnerable and struggling receive sufficient help and support.
Yours sincerely
Dr Lewis Hibell PhD
UPDATE: A REPLY 16th July 2025
It’s taken me a long time get around to writing this update, I guess it barely seemed worth it as the whole endeavour ended in a massive anticlimax.
in a way I suppose I’m grateful I received a reply (I think). I’m not sure what I really expected to be honest, some potential sources of support, contacts to try and overcome the difficulties I outlined? Either way, it seems I received a stock reply that simply seems to be a copy paste response to an incoming email that contained the acronym PIP.
At least some sign someone had taken the time to read, digest and sympathise with me would’ve been nice.
I guess, sadly, I’ll remain of the opinion that “They” aren’t interested in getting involved with the real problems of “Us”.
Dear Lewis Hibell
Thank you for contacting me to share your concerns about the proposed changes to Personal Independence Payment and Universal Credit.
I understand that the announcements and media coverage over recent months have created significant uncertainty and anxiety for many people, and I am deeply sympathetic to the fears this may have generated.
I want to reassure you that this Labour Government believes we need a welfare state that is there for all of us when we need it, now and in the future – one that protects those most in need and delivers dignity for all. There will always be people who cannot work, and I want to reassure you that the Government is committed to protecting them.
Following extensive consultation with myself and many of my colleagues in Parliament, and listening to concerns raised across the country, the Government has announced significant changes to the Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payment Bill.
Having raised my concerns with relevant Ministers, a number of changes have now been made which I will outline below.
Personal Independence Payment (PIP): The Government has decided to remove the PIP component from the current Bill entirely. This means that all existing PIP claimants will remain within the current system, and no changes will be made to PIP eligibility for new claimants until a comprehensive review is completed. This review, led by the Minister for Social Security and Disability, will be co-produced with disabled people, disability organisations, and MPs to ensure that any future changes are fair and fit for purpose. The review is expected to conclude by Autumn 2026.
When meeting with Ministers recently, I raised the need to work with disabled people and disability organisations to complete a fair review of PIP eligibility, so I particularly welcome this change.
Universal Credit: For Universal Credit, the Government has committed to protecting existing claimants. All current recipients of the health element will have their combined Universal Credit payments protected in real terms, rising at least in line with inflation. New claimants with terminal illnesses or severe, lifelong health conditions who are not expected to work will also receive this protection.
Employment Support: This Labour Government is investing an additional £300 million over the next three years in employment support for disabled people and those with serious health conditions, on top of the existing £1 billion Pathways to Work package already announced earlier this year. This includes introducing the right to try principle, which means that taking up work will not, in itself, lead to a reassessment of benefits eligibility.
I welcome that this Labour Government is investing in employment support after years of neglect and managed decline by the previous Conservative Government. And I would encourage you to examine the reforms announced in the Pathways to Work package, which has been broadly welcomed.
I firmly believe that there must be decent employment support for anyone who can and wants to work, while ensuring that our welfare system provides proper financial support for those who cannot work due to their disability or serious health condition. The system we inherited was fundamentally broken, so I welcome these changes which will ensure many more people are not written off from working.
With this in mind, I also support the Labour Government ending reassessments for PIP for disabled people who will never be able to work and for those with lifelong health conditions that will not improve, ensuring they can live with dignity. In South Dorset, many local people have told me how unfair and stressful the reassessment process was up until now; scrapping these reassessments will make a real difference for many in our community.
Nobody in South Dorset should have to worry about losing essential support, and I am committed to ensuring that any reforms protect the most vulnerable while creating a sustainable welfare system for future generations.
As there have been a number of major changes announced in recent weeks, I will continue to monitor these developments closely and I will only support reforms that genuinely support people with long-term health conditions or a disability.
And I will continue to raise my concerns – and the concerns of local people – whenever necessary.
Thank you again for taking the time to get in touch with me.
Yours sincerely,
Lloyd Hatton MP



Leave a Reply